John Clayton I, Mustache or No?

 

In Chapter One, of Tarzan Of The Apes, we are introduced to Tarzan’s father,

John Clayton I. Edgar Rice Burroughs, the narrator, (John Carter’s great-nephew)

describes him in great detail after the war.


Fred J. Arting
Fred J. Arting


     From the records of the Colonial Office and from the dead man’s diary we learn that a certain young English nobleman, whom we shall call John Clayton, Lord Greystoke, was commissioned to make a peculiarly delicate investigation of conditions in a British West Coast African Colony from whose simple native inhabitants another European power was known to be recruiting soldiers for its native army, which it used solely for the forcible collection of rubber and ivory from the savage tribes along the Congo and the Aruwimi. The natives of the British Colony complained that many of their young men were enticed away through the medium of fair and glowing promises, but that few if any ever returned to their families.

     The Englishmen in Africa went even further, saying that these poor blacks were held in virtual slavery, since after their terms of enlistment expired their ignorance was imposed upon by their white officers, and they were told that they had yet several years to serve.

   And so the Colonial Office appointed John Clayton to a new post in British West Africa, but his confidential instructions centered on a thorough investigation of the unfair treatment of black British subjects by the officers of a friendly European power. Why he was sent, is, however, of little moment to this story, for he never made an investigation, nor, in fact, did he ever reach his destination.

      Clayton was the type of Englishman that one likes best to associate with the noblest monuments of historic achievement upon a thousand victorious battlefields—a strong, virile man—mentally, morally, and physically.

      In stature he was above the average height; his eyes were gray, his features regular and strong; his carriage that of perfect, robust health influenced by his years of army training. Political ambition had caused him to seek transference from the army to the Colonial Office and so we find him, still young, entrusted with a delicate and important commission in the service of the Queen. When he received this appointment he was both elated and appalled. The preferment seemed to him in the nature of a well-merited reward for painstaking and intelligent service, and as a stepping stone to posts of greater importance and responsibility; but, on the other hand, he had been married to the Hon. Alice Rutherford for scarce a three months, and it was the thought of taking this fair young girl into the dangers and isolation of tropical Africa that appalled him.

     For her sake he would have refused the appointment, but she would not have it so. Instead she insisted that he accept, and, indeed, take her with him.

   There were mothers and brothers and sisters, and aunts and cousins to express various opinions on the subject, but as to what they severally advised history is silent.

     We know only that on a bright May morning in 1888, John, Lord Greystoke, and Lady Alice sailed from Dover on their way to Africa. ERB, Tarzan Of The Apes.


1872 Africa
1872 Africa


In Chapter Two of Tarzan Of The Apes, ERB: the narrator continues his description of John Clayton I, as he travels from Freetown, Sierra Leone, North Africa to his intended destination in Southern Africa.


J. Allen St. John
 J. Allen St. John 

                                                                                                                               

        And even should they escape that fate was it not but to be faced with far graver

dangers? Alone, he might hope to survive for years; for he was a strong, athletic man.

ERB-Tarzan Of The Apes.                      

        There was a great quantity and variety of stuff, as the Claytons had expected a possible five to eight years’ residence in their new home. Thus, in addition to the many necessities they had brought, there were also many luxuries. ERB-Tarzan Of The Apes.             

        “There is but one thing to do, Alice,” and he spoke as quietly as though they were sitting in their snug living room at home, “and that is work. Work must be our salvation. We must not give ourselves time to think, for in that direction lies madness. ERB-Tarzan Of The Apes.

In Chapter Three of Tarzan Of The Apes, ERB: the narrator provides information about John Clayton I, during his and Alice's abandonment on the coast of Portuguese Angola. 

J. Alan St. John
J. Alan St. John


        In his leisure Clayton read, often aloud to his wife, from the store of books he

had brought for their new home. Among these were many for little children—picture

books, primers, readers—for they had known that their little child would be old

enough for such before they might hope to return to England. ERB-Tarzan Of The

Apes.                             

        At other times Clayton wrote in his diary, which he had always been accustomed to keep in French, and in which he recorded the details of their strange life. This book he kept locked in a little metal box. ERB-Tarzan Of The Apes.

In Chapter Four of Tarzan Of The Apes, ERB: the narrator provides information about the long-dead John Clayton I, on the day of his death by Kerchak, King of the Mangan.                                                 

Ronald William Kirby
Ronald William Kirby

    

        Inside the den they saw the strange white ape lying half across a table, his head

buried in his arms; and on the bed lay a figure covered by a sailcloth, while from a tiny

rustic cradle came the plaintive wailing of a babe.

        Noiselessly  Kerchak entered, crouching for the charge; and then John Clayton

rose with a sudden start and faced them.

        The sight that met his eyes must have frozen him with horror, for there, within the

door, stood three great bull apes, while behind them crowded many more; how many he

never knew, for his revolvers were hanging on the far wall beside his rifle, and Kerchak

was charging.               

         When the king ape released the limp form which had been John Clayton, Lord

Greystoke, he turned his attention toward the little cradle; but Kala was there before

him,and when he would have grasped the child she snatched it herself, and before he

could intercept her she had bolted through the door and taken refuge in a high tree.

ERB-Tarzan Of The Apes.


In Chapter Eleven of Tarzan Of The Apes, ERB: the narrator describes the long-dead

John Clayton I, for the last time in a picture the ape boy found in the cabin. 

                                                                                     

Artist Unknown
Artist Unknown .

 

When Tarzan is eighteen years old his foster mother, Kala the great ape, is killed by

Kulonga the son of Chief Mbonga. Mbonga’s cannibal tribe fled the Belgian Congo after

killing a white Belgian soldier and his native unit. Fleeing for their lives Mbonga’s tribe

fled the Belgian Congo, southwest to the coastal area of Portuguese Angola, before

stopping to construct a new village. These were the first humans Tarzan had ever come

into contact with. 


Don Marquez
Don Marquez

                                                                

While seeking revenge on his foster mother’s killer the eightteen-year-old was introduced

to the spear and bow and arrows. The ape-man craved these new weapons, so that night

he stole them from the sleeping native. The following morning the jungle lord followed

Kulonga to the newly constructed village. Within sight of the cannibal village, the

vengeful tracker killed the Chief’s son and robbed him of his desired belongings.

Afterward, the jungle man entered the village, stole arrows, and played his first jungle

joke on the newly arrived natives.


Burne Hogarth
Burne Hogarth


Returning to the tribe the ape-man displayed his man treasures to his fellows. They nor

Kerchek were impressed. Despite their no interest, Tarzan practiced every day with his

newly confiscated weapons. Occasionally the jungle lord would pay a visit to the cabin

by the sea, to spend a day with his coveted books. 


Joe Kubert
Joe Kubert

                                                                                                                     

It was during this period that the young English lord found hidden in the back of one

of the cupboards in the cabin a small metal box. The key was in the lock, and a few

moments of investigation and experimentation were rewarded with the successful

opening of the receptacle.


Roy G. Krenkle
Roy G. Krenkle

In it he found a faded photograph of a smooth faced young man, a golden locket
studded with diamonds, linked to a small gold chain, a few letters and a small book.
Tarzan examined these all minutely.  


Joe Kubert
Joe Kubert

                                                                                        

The photograph he liked most of all, for the eyes were smiling, and the face was open

and frank. It was his father. ERB-Tarzan Of The Apes.


Many researchers have translated ERB's description of John Clayton I, as being

smooth-faced, into meaning clean-shaven, or beardless. Is that ERB’s intention? No, it

is not. To prove this we must leave Tarzan Of The Apes for the moment, and research

the real-life history of the mustache

  • Around 1585 the French were introduced to the mustache by the Turks. In this

period the word mustache more or less meant groomed facial hair.
  • During the Napoleonic Wars in the 1800s, the British were introduced to the

mustache by the French. The French mustache eventually went on to become
an emblem of male prestige.
  • On the other hand, when Tipu Sultan, the ruler of Mysore, celebrated his

victory over the East India Company he showed no respect for British soldiers.
He displayed a painting depicting the clean-shaven British as if they looked
boyish, or unmanly. Certainly the opposite of intimidating.
  • In 1831, the 16th Lancers of the Queen’s Army were officially permitted to wear

mustaches.
  • By the 1850s, respected journals such as The Westminster Review,

Illustrated London News: and The Naval & Military Gazette began to
present articles in support of the ‘beard and mustache movement’. 
  • In 1853, a beard proclamation was published in Charles Dickens' popular

magazine Household Words, entitled ‘Why Shave?’
  • This article promoted the benefits of facial hair so well that by 1854 Lord

Frederick Fitz Clarence, Commander in Chief of the Bombay Army of the East
India Company; gave orders making mustaches mandatory for the British
troops of the India unit.
  • The Crimean War began in October 1853 and British soldiers were once more

permitted to wear facial hair. The reason was to protect themselves from the
bitter cold. 
  • When the war ended three years later, Queen Victoria wrote in her journal dated

March 13, 1856, that the soldiers returning home ‘was the picture of real fighting
men……They all had their long beards and were heavily laden with large
knapsack’.
  • Not only in the military but after the mid-1850s, mustaches also stormed into

British civil society. Even in the colonies, it was social death for a British man if
he forgot to curl the ends of his mustache. At the gentlemen’s club, to present
yourself with a shaved upper lip was considered as shameful as forgetting to put
your trousers on.
  • By 1860 facial hair had become so accepted that mustaches had become

mandatory in the British Army. Command No.1695 of the King’s Regulations
read: ‘The chin and the under lip will be shaved, but not the upper lip. Whiskers
if worn will be of moderate length’.
  • Under English law between 1860 and 1916, every soldier in the British Army was

forbidden from shaving his upper lip. or else it would have been considered a
breach of discipline. The unshaven ‘upper lip’ thus became the norm with British
military uniform and service. 
 
British Military Styled Mustouche
British Military Styled Mustouche

                                         

  • According to Etiquette for Every Day, a perfect mustache is one “that actively

bristles at the ends and turns neither up nor down.” This was a tamed
mustache, unlike a curved droop at the corners, which suggested artistic
temperament, or an upcurled mustache characteristic of the dandy.
  • Cecil B. Hartley, in The Gentlemen’s Book of Etiquette and Manual of

Politeness; cautioned men to tread carefully along the line of ideal mustache
grooming, warning against the effeminacy of over-grooming and the indecency
of neglect: Hartley continues to say that the mustache “should never be curled,
nor pulled out to an absurd length … [It] should be neat and not too large, and
[avoid] such fopperies as cutting the points thereof, or twisting them up to the
fineness of needles.”
  • In 1870 the British Army Enlistment Act made the normal period of service

twelve years. For the infantry, the first six-year period was on active service
with the colors.
  • By the end of the 1880s, the popularity of mustaches started to decline.

Fashionable men in London started preferring a clean shave. Facial hair was
considered to harbor germs and bacteria. Shaving beards, while patients were
hospitalized, became a norm. In 1895, American inventor King Camp Gillette
came up with the idea of disposable razor blades. The practice of being
hair-free had never been so cheap and easy.

When we combine this information this is what we discover.


  • By 1860 facial hair had become so accepted that mustaches had become

mandatory in the British Army. Command No. 1695 of the King’s Regulations
read: ‘The chin and the under lip will be shaved, but not the upper lip. Whiskers
if worn will be of moderate length’.Under English law between 1860 and 1916,
every soldier in the British Army was forbidden from shaving his upper lip. or
else it would have been considered a breach of discipline. The unshaven ‘upper
lip’ thus became the norm with British military uniforms and service.
  • By descriptions of the time, a neatly trimmed mustache was considered to be

clean-shaven.
  • We know John Clayton I, pulled at least six years, could be more, in the military

before receiving his African position. 
  • In 1872 (1888) John Clayton I was described as the type of Englishman whom

one likes best to associate with the noblest monuments of historic achievement
upon a thousand victorious battlefields—a strong, virile man—mentally, morally,
and physically.
  • In stature he was above the average height; his eyes were gray, his features

regular and strong; his carriage that of perfect, robust health influenced by his
years of army training.

Since John Clayton I, had at least six years in service and was the perfect soldier, there is no doubt he dressed and groomed in the proper fashion of his time. As shown above, that would include a well-trimmed and groomed military-style mustache. Although he had upper lip hair on his face the descriptions of his time considered it clean-shaven. 

Burne Hogarth
Burne Hogarth




About The Author

James Michael Moody is a lifelong fan and collector of Edger Rice Burroughs. Moody has contributed over two hundred articles to various ERB-related fanzines over forty-five years. He also manages an unauthorized Tarzan blog titled, Greystoke Chronologist: James Michael Moody. There the researcher chronologies the Tarzan books starting in May 1872 (known as the pushback theory) instead of the more excepted date May 1888.

James Michael Moody is also the author of the action-packed Sci-Fi fantasy adventure Unium series. Pioneers On Unium, published December 31, 2019, and Exiled On Unium, published August 25, 2022. Swordsman On Unium is going through the publishing process.











No comments:

Post a Comment