Joe Ferrier Comments ERB-APA #40: A Reply

I wish I could except the 1888 birth date of Tarzan, but my research just does not allow me to do that. I will closely watch your future research to see if you offer any new twist that may change my view. Good luck and I am extremely glad you are showing interest.

Before closing I would like to ask a quick question.  You wrote, "And their baby, who was to become Tarzan of the Apes was born five months later in October of 1888 - given facts."  Unfortunately for me, I don't have a McClurg first edition to research from, I use a 50 cent Ballantine edition.  Nowhere in it  could I find a statement where ERB implies Tarzan was born five months after John and Alice sailed from Dover.  Could you please supply me the complete McClurg passage so that I may add it to my research.

I would like to point one thing out to you before moving on.  You state in ERB-APA #40 that, "ERB never wrote a damn thing about adopted cousins, time warps, a fictional account, push back sailing dates and / or a parallel Africa where the Greystoke stories took place in a never never Dark Continent."  There is one thing you left out.

ERB never wrote a dam thing about Tarzan and Jane being a whole lot younger than twenty-two and twenty when Jane first became pregnant with their baby Jack.  In fact ERB plainly and strongly hints just the opposite of what you are trying to imply.  Secondly, ERB never implied that Tarzan and Jane had a second child, after being married by Jane's father - an infant that died by age three.

When you except this theory you are drastically changing the story as presented by ERB.  Therefore, I just do not think this direction leads to the truth.  Please test my push back theory one more time. Although I can not use the 1888 sailing date as a starting point everything else in my chronology runs exactly as presented in the Tarzan series except for the modernization,

I do agree with you on one point, Joe.  "But, this beats the hell out of adopted cousins, time warps, or trashing an ERB book because it does not fit some chronological sequence."  You also agree with my findings when you say Korak was sixteen when he and Meriem marry.



James Michael Moody

No comments:

Post a Comment